What's the harm? Therapist harm and staying safe in an unregulated industry

Published on 18 November 2026 at 09:35

Image: "Two Rooms" by Derry Van Nortwick 

In any caring profession, you would hope that the individuals attracted to work in those posts would be compassionate, altruistic, and trustworthy. When we are physically and/or mentally vulnerable, it is a time where trusting someone is very difficult, but necessary. Our friends and family can be a wonderful support network, but professional input may be required. 

In the unfortunate circumstance that you needed to go to A&E, luckily you do not need to run a credential check on any of the medical staff. The medical community is regulated, which essentially means that they operate within a strict legal framework. Medical professions are governed by the General Medical Council (GMC), whereas facilities and care can also be regulated by the Care Quality Commission. It is by no means a perfect system, and it does not ensure that no harm is ever done. Sadly, medical trauma and harm from medical professionals still happens, and the legal framework they operate in should give you scope to pursue a complaint. 

There have been positive shifts towards regulation within the psychotherapeutic space, however, the reality remains that there is a long way to go in protecting the integrity of the industry. For example, there are organisational bodies that therapists can align to (you can see, and check, my membership with BACP) however this is voluntary for me to join. If my membership lapses, there is no consequence for that, and I could continue to practice as I wish. 

The reality of training to become a Psychotherapist 

I paid a lot in both time and money to get to where I am as a psychotherapist. Whilst I was working full time as a corporate girlie, I was volunteering with charities to better understand what health and social care was like. I completed an HNC in counselling skills on top of this, which was a prerequisite to get on to the diploma course. I completed my postgraduate diploma whilst working full time for a mental health charity, and maintaining a placement for my practice hours, and helping out within the crisis service as required. The postgraduate diploma is thousands of pounds, and needless to say I burned out every couple of months due to the reality of balancing such significant workloads, which I needed to do to fund my education. I do not regret a second of it, and recognise the privilege that I was supported by family and friends to make a very challenging situation work. I was very fortunate to gain so much experience working with mental health whilst studying, that gave me so much more than textbooks to learn from. Still, the reality of those years was difficult, and it required dedication, commitment, and sacrifice.  

As part of my experimentation for writing this post, I did a simple search for "CBT course". The results returned were from Groupon, Wowcher and similar sites offering training for £9 - £12. With that, and a free website, I could technically declare that I am trained in CBT. The challenge is that it is not a lie, rather it is an inaccurate representation of the work required to be trained in a therapeutic modality. Whilst I am by no means an advocate for academia (perhaps another post, another time) I have respect for education, passion for learning, and the belief that devoting time and effort to mastering something is worth the investment.

The harm that comes from a lack of regulation

I remember watching a television show called Can't Pay? We'll Take it Away years ago, and I remember one particular episode where the bailiffs arrived at a business, only to recognise the person who ran it; historically they had run up business debts and then declared the business insolvent. The person had been able to start up a new business, and run the same cycle of problematic behaviour. This is a dangerous loophole with businesses: you can keep creating new businesses under new names, and it is legal. 

This could be the same for a therapeutic business. Say you raised a complaint to a regulatory body. The complaint may be upheld, and the therapist removed from their services, but it wouldn't actually stop the individual from setting up anew and starting over.  Complaints to a regulatory body are published online, but this would not stop an opportunist from using a different name for themselves as well as their business. 

Something I saw online that made me shiver with fear was the fact that MLMs (multi-level marketing) exist in this industry. I created an Instagram for my business, and followed a lot of colleagues and other local businesses as part of that. Immediately, I was getting adverts about "how to make six figures with less clients", and  "creating this programme means I never have to worry about clients again!". I am staunchly against MLMs and everything they represent: they are predatory, based on false hope and toxic hustle culture. Their posts did the trick though, as I found myself wondering whether there was a secret to success. The answer of course is, no. The truth is, that luring people into a multi-level marketing scheme makes money for the lurer, and nobody else.  

Identifying harmful behaviours and trends

Friendship Vs Therapeutic Relationship

Years ago, in a discussion with a friend, they mentioned that they were friends with their old therapist. They had each other on social media, and kept in touch with messages every now and then. I remember my friend's confusion at the shock on my face when they told me this. I can recognise that there was a mutual, consensual agreement between two adults here, however, ethically I could not ever be friends with my clients. 

That may sound harsh, but this is from a place of integrity and protection. Whilst as a therapist I am not in a position of authority over a client, the balance of power is definitely skewed. A client is paying for my time, for their needs and mental health issues. Therapy sessions are all about confidentiality, vulnerability and building a therapeutic relationship; this is not the same as friendship, and the demands on each person in that relationship are different. Friendships are built on mutual interests and reciprocity; therapeutic relationships are somewhat one-sided and built within a professional framework. According to the BACP (1.3), dual relationships should be avoided.

Have I met clients and felt a sense of sadness that there can be no friendship after we have worked together? Yes. Have I had clients that bring out a protective side of me?  Absolutely. I am human before I am anything else. It is my responsibility to recognise these responses to others and look within myself. I am lucky that I have a wonderful supervisor to support me and ensure that I am navigating my role with integrity, honesty and safety. Any therapist who operates legitimately will have supervision arrangements in place, but also will prioritise their professional duties above all else.

 A therapeutic relationship is only as strong as the connection beneath it. Therapy is such a personal thing, you need to choose someone that you feel comfortable with and 'click' with. I can see how clients, who the burden of professionalism does not fall on, could potentially see their therapist as a friend and misunderstand the boundaries of the relationship. Again, it is the responsibility of the therapist to ensure that boundaries are solid, the relationship is clear, and that there is no space for confusion.

Accurate & Timely Note keeping 

 I am a proud planner-organiser Type A personality. I enjoy a spreadsheet, and I am a stickler for note taking. I have a personal deadline that all clinical notes must be completed within 24 hours of the session taking place. It is part of my duty of care to clients to ensure that the notes taken are accurate, clear, and respectful. For a lot of practitioners, I think the Lindsay Clancy case, and that brutal video of the Psychiatrist's notes being flagged as inaccurate, serves as a cautionary tale that any one of us could be compelled by law to share our notes. I found it so disappointing that the Psychiatrist stated, "I don't care what I have written, I know what I meant". Such a lack of accountability and defensiveness when she was clearly wrong in how she recorded her interaction with a vulnerable person. The word I keep coming back to, and will keep repeating until I cannot breathe another breath, is integrity. It is a cowardly move to attempt to shift blame on to a vulnerable person when the responsibility is ours to manage our notes and an accurate representation of what has been discussed in session.

I have it as part of my contract that I may record sessions to take to supervision. This is standard practice for therapists, but I also believe that clients should be able to record sessions too. The boundaries of this, considering confidentiality and the purpose of recording, should always be discussed and agreed prior to any recording being done.

My professional experience tells me that a lot of professionals out there in various fields refuse to be recorded; whilst I understand that things can be taken out of context, or misconstrued, I believe that overall, if this acts as a safety mechanism for those who have experienced gaslighting and manipulation, particularly from professionals, why can't we discuss this openly and agree boundaries for it? It is part of our role to model open communication, trust and honesty. 

TherapyTok

My last post touched on the correlation between social media and the lack of empathy present in our online spaces, as well as the physical world. Part of this was that I spoke about how we now share a lot more online. I won't reiterate the same points that I did, but as the heading suggests, my main focus for this piece is specifically the content online for TherapyTok, which in my opinion, is a harmful space on the internet.

I created a TikTok page for my business as part of a growth challenge that I undertook with a business consultant. I created four posts, none of which featured me at all, and I stopped. I felt strange, and not in a good way, making posts about my job. I had a list of different ideas for content, and even looking back on that now, it doesn't feel good to look at. My business model is that I treat everybody as an individual, so making generic posts felt like I was going against my own ethos. I want to be clear that I am in no way judging, criticising or condemning those who are gifted with content creation, and are in helping professions; I personally do not want to spend time or money on social media, and it did not align with how I wanted to run my business.

A colleague of mine wrote a piece about the marketing used online and sadly, TherapyTok is no stranger to it. Clickbait titles such as, "The worst thing my therapist ever said", "Why CBT is a scam", EMDR ruined my life", and "unhinged hacks for your anxiety" were just some of the titles of videos I scrolled through. TikTok allegedly has approximately 23 million videos uploaded daily, so it makes me question how this level of traffic is managed and suitably assessed before it is posted. The titles are somewhat misleading, and like most short-form content, it lacks context and nuance. Anybody could create a TikTok and post "hacks" for mental health that could be dangerous, damaging or misleading. 

Different Modalities & How They are Applied 

My final thought on this was actually drawn from some of the titles above - "Why CBT is a scam" and "EMDR ruined my life". I am trained in CBT, which is an evidence-based model. Do I think CBT is a top of the tree modality? That's a trick question, because I think to be reductive about the approaches used by therapists means that there is "good" therapy and "bad" therapy.

I loved studying CBT, and due to it's structure approach, there is a clear pathway you can work with and discuss with clients before you set out. What I didn't like was that it seemed to be a "tackle one problem at a time" approach, and rarely does the human experience allow for just one problem to present itself. I also disagree with therapy being limited, and I believe that client's should form part of that conversation about their care. I believe this is part of the issue with the NHS: they are restricted in what they can offer, and usually it is a disorder-focused plan rather than a person-centred one. 

I indulged in reading some comments on videos of this nature, and saw so many people sharing that they felt CBT was a joke, that it didn't help them at all, that it is a cheap model to deliver because it can be done without a therapist present (online programmes such as SilverCloud and Beating the Blues is what I am referring to). I felt sad, and a bit frustrated at these comments, but I lacked exactly what they did too: context. 

There is also the capability and experience of the therapists themselves. I describe myself as an holistic practitioner because my main training is in CBT. I have enough experience and further training that I don't rely solely on CBT to support clients, but I have been fortunate enough to have clients seeking more than a prescriptive therapeutic experience. I have the opportunity to expand and reflect on my practice because I am self employed, whereas when I was solely working for an organisation, it was their needs that were to be met. 

In my opinion, organisations can be contributors to harm. This is not through malevolent means, rather operational restrictions or answering to a higher power that looks at profit and KPIs rather than recovery and client growth. I am aware of one organisation where there are therapists in place for 15+ years in the same role. I don't judge those who seek and remain in a stable role; it does make me question the variety of experiences and growth you can have as a therapist. My lived experience, taking risks despite my fears, and growing and seeking new opportunities are tangible examples that I can use to support clients; how can I encourage clients to take risks, be vulnerable and push through their fears if I could not do that for myself? 

Staying Safe & Informed

How can you find a therapist, and a therapeutic modality, that suits? As someone who has had three therapists in my personal life, and operates as a therapist in my professional life, the main things I would suggest are:

  • Do your research! Read up on therapists that stand out to you, check their names on registers (BACP Register, BACP Professional Conduct Outcomes, BABCP Outcomes)
  • Take advantage of free consultation calls. It is an opportunity to get a feel for the person before you make any commitments. 
  • Do not commit to block booking with a therapist, until you are sure that you are comfortable with their approach, professionalism and personality. 
  • Consider what is important to you in a person: if you are religious, is it important that your therapist has a religion? If you identify as LGBTQ+, is it important to you that your therapist is part of the queer community? 
  • Be wary of profiles and directory listings where therapists can work with every single presenting issue. Particularly for complex trauma and severe mental health issues, seeking someone who specialises in a specific area may be more useful than someone who has a basic knowledge of the topic.
  • In addition to the above point, it is odd for a therapist to be able to support someone with every single presenting issue. There are some presenting issues that do not align with my life experience, and therefore it is not an area where I feel I can best show up for a client. For example, when there were a series of deaths of those I loved, I declined any enquiries about bereavement, because I was simply too deep in my own sadness and grief to sit with someone else's. It would suggest that a therapist has not conducted too much reflective work to recognise their own fragility, biases and blind spots, which could cause issues in session. 
  • There are hundreds of therapeutic modalities  - if a therapist claims to offer a significant amount of these, I would be dubious about their expertise. It is not to say they are not skilled, however some profiles claim to offer every therapy to drive traffic to their page. Personally, I would rather attract appropriate clients that I am likely to collaborate effectively with, than cast a wide net and waste anybody's time. 

I hope that this has been helpful. My hope for this piece is to give any curious individuals some tangible considerations for finding a suitable therapist, and that therapists can reflect on their own practice and conduct.  

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any clinic, agency, or employer. The content provided here is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute mental health treatment, formal diagnosis, or professional psychological advice. Reading this article or interacting with the author does not create a therapist-client relationship. If you are experiencing a mental health emergency or crisis, please contact your local emergency services or reach out to a crisis helpline immediately.

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.